## Correlation – II (7/365)

In the last post, I said I’d give an example of two random variables $\theta, \phi$ whose expectations are independent $E\theta \phi = E\theta E\phi$ but are not themselves independent.

For a first attempt, this turned out not to be an easy task because when coming up with an example I had to control two things: 1) making sure I can get $P(\theta = x | \phi = y) \ne p(\theta = x)$ for some $x, y$ and 2) making sure I can get $E\theta \phi = E\theta E\phi$.

I realized that to make like easier I should try to get $E\theta \phi = 0$ which means I only have to make sure one of the expectations $E\theta = 0$ and I can use $\phi$ to freely adjust to try and make $P(\theta = x | \phi = y) \ne p(\theta = x)$.

Consider a fair six-sided die. Let

$\displaystyle \theta(2) = \theta(4) = \theta(6) = 1 \text{ i.e. when even} \\ \theta(1) = \theta(3) = \theta(5) = -1 \text{ i.e. when odd} \\ \text{therefore } E\theta = 0$

Now, after playing around with $\phi$, I came up with this

$\displaystyle \phi(1) = 1 \\ \phi(2) = \phi(4) = \phi(6) = 0 \\ \phi(3) = \phi(5) = -0.5 \\ \text{therefore } E\theta\phi = \frac{1}{6} ((-1)(1) + (1)(0) + (-1)(-0.5) + (1)(0) + (-1)(-0.5) + (1)(0) ) = 0$

Yay! Now, check for non-independence

$\displaystyle p(\phi = 1 | \theta=1) = \frac{0}{3} \ne p(\phi = 1) = \frac{1}{6}$

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.